[Innocence]

no room in heresiarch for graknal wannabes...thx pass

[Wrathblood]

Hmm, personality fit could be a concern. We play well and EXPECT to play well, but we also prefer to minimize drama, elite-ism, etc and your app sort of suggests you're an elitist prima donna, which wouldn't be a fit. Its entirely possible you're not, but that's kinda how you've portrayed yourself.

As for how we treat others, have you read the other recruiting threads to get a feel for how we treat applicants? There have been quite a few just in the last week or so (for reasons you can probably guess). If not, then you haven't done a very good job of doing your homework.

[Innocence]

Harrow, on Oct 7 2009, 07:47 PM, said:

I have read several other of your applications. I actually had to get a walkthrough on your site from Nuadaa as it was new to me. I am not a prima donna. I believe it takes everyone pulling their weight. It seems to me that one person can't do it alone. I'm sure you all feel the same way. I think I just got off on the wrong foot, the only person that knows me in Heresiarch is Forte and he is a pretty good guy. I hope he doesn't get the same vibe off of me as you do.

I talked to forte, he seemed to think you have a ego like the rest of us do, given your application's tone.

you do come off like a shit eating dickhead, but I'd be willing to give you the benefit of the doubt.

we can be pretty rude to new applicants, i'm generally not one of them that is a cunt to new applicants, but when i saw your app it just screamed graknal to me, I raided with the guy for six months and that was a year ago and if I had to do it again it would still be to soon.

we have three raiding elemental shaman atm so geting a spot might be tough,

It's not necessarily that i'd turn you down completely on basis of your attitude and personality because i'm always willing to give some one a chance to prove they're a nice person(i'm a dumb bitch when it comes to second chances, I give them to every one, even people who don't necessarily deserve them)

I am not an officer, but I think we may be full of elemental shaman right now. With Resto shaman wanting our gear now more than ever, and having 3 already, the split is kind of steep. Thanks for your interest at least. In the future, using a little humbleness in your app might make the difference(Again, not as a deciding factor here, but just a general tip on interpersonal interaction)

[Drickzy]

I'm tired.

So I'm being blunt.

How many elemental shaman do we need? Pretty sure we have 2 active, and 1 semi not so active.

/shrug

[Unholyfury]

I like this app and his attitude towards raiding and being the best. More apps like this plz.

[Sobeyet]

Unholyfury, on Oct 7 2009, 11:04 PM, said:

I like this app and his attitude towards raiding and being the best. More apps like this plz.

I tend to agree on the attitude part; to me it seems more confident than arrogant. Whether he actually performs as well as he talks is another matter. The armory link doesn't seem to work and I'm too drunk to make sense of it atm, so someone else go nuts.

[Rohanna]

His gear is not that bad,
He has seen all content (minus hard modes) that we have.
He hasnt completed ToC 25 man, or Ulduar 25 but has completed them both on 10 man.

His spec is good, but his major glyph choices are interesting and I wouldn't mind hearing the theory behind them.

I also have to agree with sobe, I haven't talked to him so I know nothing outside this thread he doesn't come off as much more than confident, maybe I am missing something.

But I cannot say wether we need another elemental shaman either.

[Innocence]

Rohanna, on Oct 8 2009, 11:26 AM, said:

His gear is not that bad,
He has seen all content (minus hard modes) that we have.
He hasnt completed ToC 25 man, or Ulduar 25 but has completed them both on 10 man.

His spec is good, but his major glyph choices are interesting and I wouldn't mind hearing the theory behind them.

I also have to agree with sobe, I haven't talked to him so I know nothing outside this thread he doesn't come off as much more than confident, maybe I am missing something.

But I cannot say wether we need another elemental shaman either.

Seems like he thinks Crit is more important than haste, he seems to have an aweful lot of crit and a slim amount of haste. Glyph of flame tongue would also support this theory. Itemization wise, haste is much more important than crit, haste is second only to spell power(Or hit rating if you are under cap)

he's also got 400-450 hit rating(I checked last night and he had like 407, and this morning he had like 453) which is way to god damn much hit rating, at that point you want to start taking items with spirit and mp5 that -dont- have hit rating(haste instead would be preferable but even more crit would be better than all that hit, so long as he doesn't sacrifice to much spell power in the switch)

Forte informed me he's a skilled player, his gear checks out, his raiding philosophy checks out. his experiance checks out.

I'd be eager to see more proof of his ability, but he's got my check, Ultimately up to the officers if we need another elemental shaman or not. I do not think we do, but if he helps us raid 4 nights a week with 25 poeple, then more them merrier.

[Forte]

Harrow, on Oct 7 2009, 09:19 PM, said:

Haha, I was not aware I had an ego, thanks Forte but anyway, thank you for the input, I have heard good things about your guild and I hope you will give me a chance.

Hey I totally said that you were a skilled player too, but Inno is just out to make me look like a jerk

[Drickzy]

Fort, on Oct 8 2009, 06:36 PM, said:

Hey I totally said that you were a skilled player too, but Inno is just out to make me look like a jerk

I

Love

Your

Avatar <3

[Sobeyet]

Harrow, on Oct 8 2009, 08:52 PM, said:

Yeah the hit is a bit of an issue, I have picked up many pieces that are filled with hit, I have just been trying to pick up as many pieces as I can and then rotate them around as needed to reach the hit cap. I really wanted to get a trophy before I spent the emblems, but it appears I have no choice in the matter. I will pick the upgrade with the least amount of hit rating on it and then see what I can do from there. I may even have to look at equipping an old piece of SP Haste Crit gear.

I doubt that's going to be what keeps you from getting into the guild so I wouldn't inconvenience yourself too much. If anything it's the number of shaman/casters. But I'd also bet good money a couple of the new recruits end up flaking out / not performing up to par, so who knows what'll happen in the future.